More to Worry About Than Just Pensions

JULY 31, 2012

There is no doubt that Maryland (and many, many other states) are in dire need of pension reform. Simply put: we have made too many expensive promises to too many people and allocated too little money for the fulfillment of those promises. And the time is coming when our state and local governments will have to either break those promises or simply tax the rest of us more just to make good.

Marc wrote a great blog post yesterday about how Maryland should scrap the special session for gambling (and pitbull legislation) and focus on something really useful and necessary: pension reform. I couldn’t agree more. Why are we spending so much time focusing on side-issues this year when there are some very real problems facing Maryland that go largely ignored?

But we have more to worry about than just pensions. Sure, pensions get a lot of the attention, but they’re actually a smaller (though still potentially catastrophic) issue than OPEBs: other post-employment benefits.

Last year, I compiled pension and OPEB data from all the counties in Maryland and created an interactive map displaying just how big the pension/OPEB gap in each county is. The map tells a cautionary tale, but if you download the data, you can see an even more startling one.

The majority of counties had (as of last year) unfunded liabilities in their pension funds. Full data wasn’t available for each and every county, but the worst seems to be Carroll County, with 54% of its pension obligations unfunded. Keep in mind this was last year – before the dismal performance of our investments most recently. Things have likely gotten worse.

But OPEBs are much further behind than pensions. The average unfunded liability per county for OPEBs is more than twice the average unfunded liability per county for pensions. Eleven counties have unfunded liability ratios at 100%! (This fact is so discouraging that, as I write this blog post, I honestly hope that I made some very big and stupid errors during my research phase last year.)

Why are OPEBs in such a woeful state of underfunding? Because they were never supposed to be as big and expense as they have become. Healthcare benefits were never supposed to become so expensive for state and county employees. But public unions are powerful and healthcare costs are rising much faster than they should be. And so counties have had to scramble to establish similar funds for OPEBs as they have for pensions.

It is certainly true that our state and local governments need to address pensions – and soon. But we are kidding ourselves if we think that that’s the only issue that needs addressing. Once we get pensions under control, we still have to worry about OPEBs.

These citizens have paid into these pension plans their entire careers. The money was suppose to be invested but was mismanaged by the governments. Our politicians take advantage of enormous pensions and other benefits, after as little as 4 years service. We should be looking into reducing their pensions not the citizens who have worked and paid into these pensions for most of their lives.

posted by : Rachel Johnson on July 31, 2012 at 11:30 AM

Pension removal for state politicians should be a November referendum issue! THEY all have other sources of income, as well as double dipping on pensions at taxpayer and LOYAL PUBLIC EMPLOYEE expense!

posted by : Gymmybob on July 31, 2012 at 12:12 AM

Rachel, you make a great point. While it's true that their pensions may be a bit more generous than most others, it's also true that they have been paying into the funds and have been working under the assumption that they're going to get the compensation they signed on for. Changing them abruptly isn't exactly fair. Unfortunately, we're running out of options fast! That's what makes this such a scary issue. No one wants to be the bad guy...

posted by : John J. Walters on July 31, 2012 at 03:16 PM

casquette superman
new era casquette
Nike Air Jordan Retro Shoes for Men
nike air jordan Black Cement Shoes
coach outlet stores
tn nike
chaussures nike pas cher
coach factory outlet coupon
tn requin
Nike Kobe
chaussure nike homme
Nike Lebron 6
coach outlet stores online
veste en jean
tn nike
casquette lakers
coach outlet online sale
Nike Air Max Wright NM
nike 6.0 pas cher
casquette americaine

http://coachoutletonline66.com
http://www.jordanretro14air.com
http://www.foot-center.fr
http://www.colundi.com
http://Niketnpascher001.fr
http://Niketnpascher033.fr
http://Niketnpascher015.fr
http://www.spartooo.fr
http://nikekobe33.com
http://nikeairmax22.com

posted by : fespuwyp on May 20, 2013 at 01:10 AM

Name *
E-mail *
Response *


* = Required

More to Worry About Than Just Pensions

Post Your Comment Here

Policy Blog